This topic is about someone seeking advice and experiences regarding colorectal and abdominal surgeons at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota. They have been referred to Dr. McKenna for a total colectomy with a permanent ileostomy and rectal closure but are having trouble finding reviews about him. They are reaching out for personal experiences with Dr. McKenna or other surgeons at the clinic. Here are some helpful insights and advice shared by others:

1. Positive surgeon references:
- Dr. David Turay, a general surgeon at Mayo Rochester, is praised for his surgical skills and excellent bedside manner. One patient credits him with providing life-saving care.
- Dr. Scott Kelly, a colorectal surgeon at Mayo Rochester, comes highly recommended by Dr. Turay. However, patients have noted that there can be long wait times for appointments with him.
- There have been no negative reports about Dr. McKenna. At least two patients on the forum are either scheduled with him or are already under his care.

2. Managing surgeon selection and second opinions:
- If you have any doubts about the referred surgeon, consider scheduling a second opinion with another provider who has strong patient reviews.
- Whenever possible, rely on first-hand patient experiences rather than sparse or conflicting online ratings.

3. Research resources:
- The Minneapolis/St. Paul Magazine publishes an annual “Best Doctors in Minnesota” list. Checking current and past issues can help identify highly rated surgeons in various specialties.

4. Practical Mayo Clinic tips:
- For those traveling to Mayo Rochester, another patient offers to share information on lodging and dining options for family members or caregivers who may accompany you.